Ninja Creami Shopping List

I have compiled an easy to reference shopping list for all of our Ninja Creami Recipes. The Ninja Creami recipes I have on this site are all the ones that I have tested and liked. My rejects do not make the cut!!

That has culminated into a large list of ingredients.

Pace yourself! You do not need to buy everything at once. Below I have broken things down by sections. Start with a machine of course, then grab some staples. A Ninja Creami vanilla recipe can be the base for so many combinations, maybe you want to perfect that first.

Healthy ingredients make delicious, healthy Ninja Creami recipes!

I have provided Amazon links to make it easier to identify the products I have tested, love and use in my Ninja Creami recipes. I make a small commission on purchases bought through my links.

Ninja Creami Machines + Kitchen Tools

Equipment used to make delicious, high-protein yummy ice cream:

Ninja Creami Deluxe (larger capacity and more features)
Ninja Creami Deluxe - Extra Containers
Ninja Creami Regular (the original, smaller capacity with less features)
Ninja Creami Regular - Extra Containers

Ninja Creami Recipes - Ingredients

These are the ingredients I have on hand all of the time to make my recipes. You don't have to go out and buy everything at once, but you'll want the staples. I have separated them into the staples, protein powders and the flavorings.

Ninja Creami Recipes - Staples

Xanthan Gum (this is a thickener)
Allulose Sweetener (or your favorite sweetener if not using sugar)
Whole Milk (you can use skim as well but will not be as creamy)
Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract (or any vanilla extract of your choosing)
Fat Free, Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding mix (this is for flavor and thickening)

Ninja Creami Recipes - Protein Powder

Below are many of the protein powders I have on hand at any given time. It seems extreme, but each one has a different amount of protein and sweetness, so I use different ones to get the balance of each recipe that suits me. I. suggest you play around with one recipe at a time and tweak it to your tastes.

Quest Vanilla Protein Powder (perfect sweetness for the Ninja Creami Vanilla recipe)
Prolific Isolate Protein Powder (this is great to add protein without more sweetness - it is a huge bottle, so lasts a long time)
Fairlife Core Protein Vanilla Shake
Premier Protein Vanilla Shake
Premier Protein Bananas & Cream Shake
Premier Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Shake
PE Science Strawberry Cheesecake Protein Powder
PE Science Chocolate Truffle Protein Powder

Ninja Creami Recipes - Flavorings

Dole Pineapple Chunks (this is a must have for the Ninja Creami Dole Whip recipe)
Strawberry Powder (freeze dried)
Mini Dark Chocolate Chunks (I usually use chips from the grocery store)
Herschey's Simply 5 Chocolate Sauce (find at your grocery store - too expensive on Amazon)